Greek astrology vs indian astrology

Kane gave him copies of Yavanajataka obtained from Nepal. The Yavanas were ancient Indians, who dispersed from India and they are mentioned in ancient Indian texts. Some Yavanas went to the west and the others to the Eastern India Pragjyotishpur. Pragjyotishpur means the city of the earliest astronomy and astrology But Pingree thought that Yavanajataka was written by Greeks, even though he could not get a single ancient Greek manuscript on astronomy and astrology combined, whereas he could prepare a bibliography of hundreds of Indian manuscript on the subject.

Varaha Mihira was born in the 2nd century BCE and he mentioned the works of ancient Indian astronomy and astrology. Pingree stated that Varaha Mihira was born in the 6th century CE to prove his point and facilitate his thesis. Pingree is the worst literary swindler of the recent times. His PhD dissertation is nothing but a trash, as it is based on false premises. This article is really nice. Is it belongs to Tamil or Sanskrit?. Enter your email address below to subscribe to this blog and receive new posts by email:. I recently participated in a debate on the topic of modern versus traditional astrology, with astrologer Eric Meyers representing the modern approach, while I represented the traditional approach.

As part of the debate each of us …. Rob Hand wins the Lifetime Achievement Award at the United Astrological Conference in , but is then unexpectedly interrupted during his acceptance speech…. I recently released a new set of posters that depict the astrology of , and while I was working on creating those it gave me some time to reflect on the major planetary alignments that ….

I am pleased to announce that my long-awaited book on ancient astrology has finally been released, and it is titled Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune. The book was actually published in February, but …. This is a list of the most famous and most influential astrologers of all time. The list mainly covers astrologers who played an important role in the astrological tradition over the past 3, years, and it ….

This was the very first time that the three …. Linguistic Evidence of the Transmission The strongest evidence that Indian astrology is of Greek origin is, as Pingree pointed out, the fact that many of the technical terms in the early Indian tradition, and even today, are simply transliterations of Greek terms into Sanskrit. Synthesis of the Hellenistic and Indian Astrological Traditions The astrology that was imported into India from Egypt was merged with the indigenous form of lunar astrology known as the nakshatras.

Indian Astrology Today An interesting result of this transmission is that Indian astrology today, in the 21st century, is much more similar to the original form of Hellenistic astrology than modern western astrology is to Hellenistic astrology. Pingree published his critical edition of the Yavanajataka as well as his English translation and commentary as a two volume set in The first volume contains the Sanskrit text itself along with a critical apparatus and brief introduction.

Volume 2 contains his English translation of the Yavanajataka along with his commentary. January 15, at pm. Chris Brennan says:. Nash says:. January 16, at am. Jacqui Menkes says:. January 31, at am. Sonja Foxe says:. March 29, at am. Sameer says:. January 2, at pm. January 3, at am. January 5, at am. Soma says:. January 31, at pm. February 2, at pm. February 3, at pm.

John D. February 14, at pm. February 18, at am.


  • Difference Between Hindu Astrology And Western Astrology | Difference Between.
  • Ayanāṃśa – or where exactly does the sidereal zodiac begin?.
  • born 15 october pisces horoscope?
  • Recent Posts?

Bhattacharjya says:. May 11, at pm. Rajesh says:. Black Cohosh- […]. We import from all over the world and also carry a […]. Walk-ins welcome or call […]. Books We have a large collection of new and used books,. Books and More. Our Herbal Friends. To allow it to remain an ineffable blessing and mystery… Thanks Chris for posting.

5 Basic Differences Between Vedic Astrology and Western Astrology

We are talking about the oldest sacred surviving text on this green Earth, and to it match it side by side with a single kosmic download, is ridic. I feel the truth is, we cannot know. How can we really know? Just like Carl Sagan having tea with Sri Aurobindo…. Namaste my friend. To this I would have to say show me the references to horoscopic astrology in the Vedas, otherwise explain why they are not there if the system was revealed 5, years ago and it supposedly played just as integral a part of the religion then as it does today.

I was speaking about Astrology and its many limbs—Horary etc. Astrology is one of the 6 limbs of the Vedic canon. Just because they didnt have the horoscope they use today which was influenced so much by the Greeks, doesnt mean they still werent phenomenal Astrologers…?

You down? We should meet up in person sometime though, since we both live in the same area. Do you ever go to ROMA meetings? I havent ever been to a ROMA meeting. Eric Meyers invited me to one, but I never attended. They fun? Where are you at in the front range? Thanks for this, it has helped a lot. Thanks again.


  1. Differences Between the Chinese Zodiac and Western Astrology.
  2. 23 october eclipse astrology.
  3. virgo born january 14 horoscope.
  4. The Relation of Hellenistic to Indian Astrology.
  5. libra november 6 weekly horoscope?
  6. The current Sakawadippi spelling? Brahmins would be a valuable resource … according to my understanding they came to India with Cyrus armies Magi and claim to have learned astrology from Zoroaster. David Pingree came to India in Kane gave him copies of Yavanajataka obtained from Nepal. The Yavanas were ancient Indians, who dispersed from India and they are mentioned in ancient Indian texts. Some Yavanas went to the west and the others to the Eastern India Pragjyotishpur. Pragjyotishpur means the city of the earliest astronomy and astrology But Pingree thought that Yavanajataka was written by Greeks, even though he could not get a single ancient Greek manuscript on astronomy and astrology combined, whereas he could prepare a bibliography of hundreds of Indian manuscript on the subject.

    The Transmission of Hellenistic Astrology to India

    Varaha Mihira was born in the 2nd century BCE and he mentioned the works of ancient Indian astronomy and astrology. Pingree stated that Varaha Mihira was born in the 6th century CE to prove his point and facilitate his thesis. Pingree is the worst literary swindler of the recent times. His PhD dissertation is nothing but a trash, as it is based on false premises. This article is really nice. Is it belongs to Tamil or Sanskrit?. Enter your email address below to subscribe to this blog and receive new posts by email:.

    I recently participated in a debate on the topic of modern versus traditional astrology, with astrologer Eric Meyers representing the modern approach, while I represented the traditional approach. As part of the debate each of us …. Rob Hand wins the Lifetime Achievement Award at the United Astrological Conference in , but is then unexpectedly interrupted during his acceptance speech…. I recently released a new set of posters that depict the astrology of , and while I was working on creating those it gave me some time to reflect on the major planetary alignments that ….

    Tropical Zodiac vs Sidereal Zodiac?

    I am pleased to announce that my long-awaited book on ancient astrology has finally been released, and it is titled Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune. The book was actually published in February, but …. This is a list of the most famous and most influential astrologers of all time. The list mainly covers astrologers who played an important role in the astrological tradition over the past 3, years, and it ….

    This was the very first time that the three …. Linguistic Evidence of the Transmission The strongest evidence that Indian astrology is of Greek origin is, as Pingree pointed out, the fact that many of the technical terms in the early Indian tradition, and even today, are simply transliterations of Greek terms into Sanskrit. Synthesis of the Hellenistic and Indian Astrological Traditions The astrology that was imported into India from Egypt was merged with the indigenous form of lunar astrology known as the nakshatras.

    Indian Astrology Today An interesting result of this transmission is that Indian astrology today, in the 21st century, is much more similar to the original form of Hellenistic astrology than modern western astrology is to Hellenistic astrology. Pingree published his critical edition of the Yavanajataka as well as his English translation and commentary as a two volume set in The first volume contains the Sanskrit text itself along with a critical apparatus and brief introduction.

    Volume 2 contains his English translation of the Yavanajataka along with his commentary.